Search EdWorkingPapers

The Causal Impact of Charter Schools on Private Tutoring Prevalence

Greater school choice leads to lower demand for private tutoring according to various international studies, but this has not been explicitly tested for the U.S. context. To estimate the causal effect of charter school appearances on neighboring private tutoring prevalence, we employ a comparative event study model combined with a longitudinal matching strategy to accommodate differing treatment years. In contrast to findings from other countries, we estimate that charter schools increase, rather than decrease, tutoring prevalence in the United States. We further find that the effect varies considerably based on the characteristics of the treated neighborhood: areas with the highest income, educational attainment, and proportion Asian show the greatest treatment impacts, while the areas with the least show null effects. Moreover, methodologically this investigation offers a pipeline for flexibly estimating causal effects with observational, longitudinal, geographically located data.

Charter Schools, Private Tutoring, Causal Inference
Education level
Document Object Identifier (DOI)

EdWorkingPaper suggested citation:

Kim, Edward J., and Luke W. Miratrix. (). The Causal Impact of Charter Schools on Private Tutoring Prevalence. (EdWorkingPaper: 23-756). Retrieved from Annenberg Institute at Brown University:

Machine-readable bibliographic record: RIS, BibTeX