Search EdWorkingPapers

Bending Without Breaking - COVID-19 Tests the Resilience of State Education Policymaking Institutions

COVID-19 upended schooling across the United States, but with what consequences for the state-level institutions that drive most education policy? This paper reports findings on two related research questions. First, what were the most important ways state government education policymakers changed schools and schooling from the moment they began to reckon with the seriousness of COVID-19 through the first full academic year of the pandemic? Second, how deep did those changes go – are there indications the pandemic triggered efforts to make lasting changes in states’ education policymaking institutions? Using multiple-methods research focused on Colorado, Florida, Louisiana, Michigan, and Oregon, we documented policies enacted during the period from March 2020 through June 2021 across states and across sectors (traditional and choice) in three COVID-19-related education policy domains: school closings and reopenings, budgeting and resource allocation, and assessment and accountability systems. We found that states quickly enacted radical changes to policies that had taken generations to develop. They mandated sweeping school closures in Spring 2020, and then a diverse array of school reopening policies in the 2020/2021 school year. States temporarily modified their attendance-based funding systems and allocated massive federal COVID-19 relief funds. Finally, states suspended annual student testing, modified the wide array of accountability policies and programs linked to the results of those tests, and adapted to new assessment methods. These crisis-driven policy changes deeply disrupted long-established patterns and practices in education. Despite this, we found that state education governance systems remained resilient, and that at least during the first 16 months of the pandemic, stakeholders showed little interest in using the crisis to trigger more lasting institutional change. We hope these findings enable state policymakers to better prepare for future crises.

COVID-19, State policymaking, Institutional change
Education level
Document Object Identifier (DOI)

EdWorkingPaper suggested citation:

Menefee-Libey, David, Carolyn Herrington, Kyoung-Jun Choi, Julie Marsh, and Katrina Bulkley. (). Bending Without Breaking - COVID-19 Tests the Resilience of State Education Policymaking Institutions. (EdWorkingPaper: 23-888). Retrieved from Annenberg Institute at Brown University:

Machine-readable bibliographic record: RIS, BibTeX