Youth Outcome Toolkit
Category: Student Well-Being
Abstract: Critical race theory (CRT) and claims of political indoctrination in K-12 classrooms are at the forefront of the ongoing culture wars surrounding public education. Despite a wave of legislative action targeting CRT-related instruction, little systematic evidence documents the extent to which critics’ claims have merit. Using a nationally representative survey of American high school students, we examine the frequency with which students are exposed to CRT-related content and political bias in their classrooms. We further examine how students’ experiences differ by political preference, race/ethnicity, and local political context, finding that classroom content likely mirrors community preferences. Our findings suggest that while some divisive topics are discussed, their frequency and context do not support the claims of the most vocal critics.
An opinion essay by Ken Futernick arguing that the real classroom problem is public mistrust of teachers, not indoctrination. It cites and links the Annenberg working paper by Gary Ritter, Brian Kisida and colleagues, whose student survey found no widespread indoctrination.
A research article by Brian Kisida, Gary Ritter and colleagues reporting a national survey of high school students about classroom instruction on race and divisive topics. It presents the findings of the same research team's study on claims of critical race theory and indoctrination in classrooms.