Meriden School Climate Survey-Student Version (MSCS-SV)
Category: Student Well-Being
Abstract: Many of the most tangible and immediate political conflicts in Americans’ lives occur at the local level. Yet, we lack large-scale evidence on how, why, and where conflict occurs in local governments. In this paper, we present a new dataset of nearly 100,000 videos of school board meetings, and use them to create a new measure of local political conflict. We validate this new approach using sentiment analysis and structural topic modeling. We then document consistent results: conflict in school board meetings occurs at some point for most boards and has become more common since 2020, but the most intense conflicts are concentrated in a small number of districts; this conflict often centers cultural issues like racial diversity and gender identity. We then show that conflict, particularly cultural conflict, is most likely to occur in larger school districts in cities and suburbs and in places with more White students.
A chapter of a Brookings report on school board members' views of the pandemic and culture-war era. It links to the EdWorkingPaper measuring conflict in local politics as evidence that board-community conflict was concentrated in a few districts.
An essay on strained relationships between parents and schools. It cites and links to the EdWorkingPaper measuring conflict in local politics through school board meeting videos, which found rising but still limited conflict.
A news story on a working paper that measured conflict in about 100,000 school board meeting transcripts. Co-author Tyler Simko explains that most meetings are civil and that high-conflict meetings cluster in a small number of city and suburban districts.