Survey of Attendance Practices
Category: Student Well-Being
Abstract: Superintendents shape conditions for teaching and learning, yet the limited studies of their impact—concentrated in a few states and focused on superintendent turnover—find small or null effects on student achievement. Using more than 37,000 district-year records from national superintendents and student achievement datasets, and drawing on organizational learning and managerial succession theories, I reframe superintendent influence as a district’s cumulative leadership stability rather than a discrete turnover event. I find that districts with more instability had lower achievement, and the penalty grew with each additional departure. The penalty was larger when departures were contentious and concentrated in the highest-poverty districts. A within-district analysis of discrete turnover events yielded no reliable effects, underscoring that measurement shapes whether superintendents appear to matter.
Chalkbeat Tennessee story on a Vanderbilt study (with Jason Grissom) of why Tennessee superintendents leave, finding internal hires stay longer. It links that EdWorkingPaper and a second EdWorkingPaper on superintendent instability and student achievement.
An Education Week article on how superintendent turnover affects student learning. It centers on Rachel White's Annenberg working paper linking repeated leadership changes to lost math learning, with interview quotes from White.
Chalkbeat Detroit explainer on the stakes of the 2026 Detroit school board election, including the superintendent's future. It links the EdWorkingPaper on superintendent instability and student achievement to note that leadership churn can hurt achievement.
An exclusive report on superintendent turnover and student outcomes. It is built around a new paper by Rachel White finding that students in high-poverty districts with repeated leadership churn fell behind in math and reading.