From Candidate to Classroom: Research-Based Practices for Recruiting and Hiring Highly-Effective Teachers
Category: Staffing, Finance, and Operations
Abstract: Research has examined many facets of superintendent turnover but offers an incomplete understanding of superintendents’ pathways out of the role. We pair administrative data on Tennessee superintendents over 15 years with hand-collected information about the reported reasons for their departures and jobs they took after leaving. Our data show that interpreting exits from state administrative data as synonymous with exits from the workforce (i.e., retirement) is misleading. More than a third of superintendents continue working after appearing to leave, including out-of-state. Even among superintendents for whom “retirement” is the publicly reported reason for leaving the superintendency, 22% hold future roles in or outside education. Age is the most important predictor of labor force exit. Superintendents are also more likely to exit following turnover on the school board. Low school district performance predicts neither exits nor moves within the superintendency but does predict “downward” moves into central office or school-level positions.
Chalkbeat Tennessee story on a Vanderbilt study (with Jason Grissom) of why Tennessee superintendents leave, finding internal hires stay longer. It links that EdWorkingPaper and a second EdWorkingPaper on superintendent instability and student achievement.