EdWorkingPapers
The Effects of Standalone Digital Learning Programs on PreK–12 Mathematics and Science Achievement: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials
Most reviews of educational technology pool programs that supplement teachers with programs that teach on their own. We synthesized 68 randomized controlled trials (147 effect sizes) of standalone digital learning programs in PreK–12 mathematics and science, compared with traditional in-person classroom instruction. Using correlated and hierarchical effects models with robust variance estimation,… more →
How do government regulations affect private school decisions to participate in choice programs? Experimental evidence from a national sample
School choice legislation continues to expand in the United States. Currently, 35 states plus Washington, D.C., offer some form of a private K-12 choice program, which allows families to receive a taxpayer subsidy to offset the costs of sending their children to a private school or other private education provider. Some have argued for more stringent regulations under these programs to hold… more →
The Details Matter: A Systematic Review of School Choice Policy and Implementation Research
At least one-third of students no longer attend their neighborhood public schools due to the growth of school choice policies. We systematically review the empirical literature on nine key elements of policy that affect how choice works (e.g., transportation, information, and choice school accountability). We conclude, first, that many aspects of choice policy improve access to choice schools.… more →
Does in-service training in special education increase the effectiveness of general classroom teachers? Evidence from the large-scale “Special Education Pedagogy for Learning” program in Sweden
Causal evidence on the effectiveness of general teacher training in special education is scarce. This study evaluates the “Special Education Pedagogy for Learning” (SFL) program, a professional development program for general classroom teachers in Sweden involving approximately 60,000 teachers. Linking program administrative data to full-population register data, we estimate dynamic difference-in… more →
Performance Pay and Teacher Mobility: Statewide Evidence from Texas
Texas's Teacher Incentive Allotment (TIA) provides performance-based funding to school districts, with larger awards at rural campuses and campuses serving more disadvantaged students. I study whether district adoption keeps teachers in their districts and at their schools. Using statewide administrative teacher records covering 2014--15 through 2025--26 and a staggered difference-in-differences… more →
Cultivating STEM Interest in Middle School Students: Evidence from a Randomized Controlled Trial of an Out-of-School Time Experiential Learning Program
A sustainable science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) workforce is central to U.S. national interests and policy debates. Researchers and practitioners often overlook non-academic levers such as early interest and career aspirations. One way to foster these dispositions is through out-of-school time (OST) programs that provide learning experiences not typically offered in school… more →
Navigating Conflicting Pressures: How Districts Spend Federal COVID-19 Relief Funds
Federal COVID-19 relief funds provided a large increase in school district revenue, with fewer requirements than usual. Districts received widespread criticism, based on little systematic evidence, for spending federal funds slowly or ineffectively. Institutional theories predict a common response to funds across districts, while other theories predict variation in use of these funds. How have… more →
When Advanced Learning Programs Expand: Evidence on Access and Achievement
This paper examines how a district-wide expansion of an advanced learning program reshaped access and short-run academic outcomes. The reform replaced an opt-in identification process with universal screening based on district assessments and expanded program capacity, resulting in larger entering cohorts and a participant pool that more closely reflected the district’s student population.… more →
Empty Desks: Schools and Staffing after the Pandemic
Sustained enrollment losses and other post-pandemic factors have placed budgetary pressures on many school districts and motivated difficult discussions about both closing under enrolled schools and staffing reductions. Using the most currently available national data, this brief provides descriptive evidence on trends in the number of operating schools and their teacher staffing and discusses… more →
Interpreting Null Effects in Education: Insights from a Tutoring Experiment
We learn not only from when interventions work—but also from why they do not. Policymakers embraced high impact tutoring to address pandemic learning loss, but scaling promising practices is difficult, and not all implementations prove effective. Using random assignment, we find null (math and a low-stakes reading test) and negative (-0.09 SD on state reading scores) impacts from assignment to a… more →
Increasing Take-Up of Literacy Tutoring: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment
Government programs often experience low take-up, limiting their potential positive impact. We examine whether reducing registration frictions can increase participation in a state-financed literacy intervention program. In a randomized field experiment, families received either encouragement and a simplified enrollment process, or these interventions plus text message nudges, relative to a… more →
Enhancing Teacher Productivity with Information on Students and Skills: Experimental Evidence from Bangladesh
Teachers may fail to address learning gaps because they do not know which students and skills need support. While exams are prevalent in every education system, these tests often go underutilized. We evaluate an intervention that provided grade-6 math teachers in 312 schools in Bangladesh with results from two brief tests, reports identifying topics and students in need of support, and an… more →
The Returns to Private Tutoring Centers
Private tutoring centers have expanded rapidly across the United States, yet there is little evidence on whether these centers improve student outcomes. Using business records on tutoring establishments linked to administrative data covering over five million public school students in Texas, this paper estimates the short- and long-run impacts of tutoring centers. Exploiting variation from the… more →
Does Liberal Education Produce Engaged Citizens? The Relationship Between Curricular Breadth, Depth, and Democratic Outcomes
Liberal education is often touted as an ideal format for preparing students for civic engagement, yet this claim is seldom empirically tested. In this study, we quantify the relationship between college students’ liberal education, measured by the breadth and depth of their curriculum, and markers of civic engagement in four domains: participating in civic life, acting politically, being informed… more →
Aligned Pathways, Unequal Earnings: Gendered Transitions from Community College to Work
States increasingly use financial aid policy to steer students into designated high-demand workforce fields, yet evidence on whether these fields offer stronger labor-market pathways remains limited. We study Virginia's Get a Skill, Get a Job, Get Ahead (G3) initiative, which provides tuition-free community college to income-eligible students in high-demand workforce areas. Using linked community… more →
Big P and Little P Politics: Contemporary and Enduring Challenges for K-12 School Board Members
School board service has become more complex in the current era of heightened partisan polarization and the nationalization of education. This mixed-methods paper draws on interviews with and a statewide survey of board members in California, and the theory of emotional labor. We explore how members experience contemporary national issues (“Big P Politics”), and everyday challenges of managing… more →
Building the STEM Talent Pipeline: The Impact of Project Lead the Way
Project Lead the Way (PLTW) is an applied STEM Career Technical Education program that has been adopted widely across the country. Using data from Missouri, we investigate the impact of PLTW course expansion on program participation and early post-secondary outcomes overall and by gender. Our identification strategies rely on within-school between-cohort variation in PLTW course availability,… more →
Facilitating Evidence-Based Instructional Coaching With Automated Feedback on Teacher Discourse
Instructional coaching often aims to ground teacher professional learning in classroom evidence, yet it is labor-intensive for coaches to obtain and curate such evidence. This study explores possibilities for applying an automated feedback tool to classroom recordings in order to support evidence-based reflection in coaching. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 9 coaches and coded 25… more →
The New Kid on the Tutoring Block: Definitions, Developments, and Future Directions for Hybrid Human-AI Tutoring
Human tutoring is among the most effective educational interventions, yet high costs and intensive resource demands make it difficult to provide broadly and at scale. We conceptualize this tension as an “iron triangle” of tradeoffs between effectiveness, affordability, and scalable reach. This essay examines how an emerging genre of tutoring, hybrid human-AI tutoring, reconfigures these tradeoffs… more →
Variation in Post-Pandemic Postsecondary Transitions across Academic Subgroups
We examine how trends in postsecondary readiness and enrollment from pre- to post-pandemic differ across student subgroups defined by pre-pandemic (8th grade) achievement levels. Using individual-level data from North Carolina and interrupted time series approaches, we find that students with high baseline achievement became less likely to apply to and enroll in a four-year college following the… more →
The Contributions of School and Neighborhood Factors to Student Attendance Following the COVID-19 Pandemic
Student attendance remains well below pre-COVID pandemic levels, yet districts lack evidence about which levers are most influential. Whether school and neighborhood contexts still account for meaningful variation in attendance, especially for students with weaker attendance histories, is an open question. Using a longitudinal database of over 360,000 Chicago Public Schools students in grades 6… more →
Not Too Young to Notice: The Early Emergence of Racial Disparities in Elementary Students’ School Climate Perceptions
School Climate scholarship often fails to explore the perspectives of elementary-school students. To fill this gap, we use survey-data from Georgia to examine racial disparities in elementaryschool students’ school climate perceptions, how they vary over time, and the factors that associate with them. We find that Black and "Other Race" students report worse school climate perceptions than their… more →
The Burden of Waiting: Temporal Administrative Burden and Limbo in Student Loan Repayment
Research on administrative burden establishes that interactions with government impose learning, compliance, and psychological costs. However, less is known about how these costs persist or reemerge after an administrative encounter has seemingly ended. Drawing on interviews with 72 student loan borrowers, I examine how prolonged administrative uncertainty shapes experiences with income-driven… more →
From the Right to Education to the Distribution of Resources: Testing U.S. School Finance Equity Metrics in Mexico, Brazil and France
Most national constitutions and international treaties guarantee a right to education, and the Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights has warned that sharp geographic disparities in spending may constitute discrimination. Yet rights monitoring rarely tests whether resources within a country follow children's needs. U.S. school finance research offers a transferable method for doing so.… more →
School Impacts on Absenteeism in the High School Grades following the COVID-19 Pandemic: Identifying School Factors and Strategies for Improvement
Chronic absenteeism has increased sharply in U.S. high schools following the COVID-19 pandemic, with Chicago Public Schools (CPS) mirroring national trends. Although student attendance has long been recognized as a critical factor in academic success, persistently high chronic absenteeism rates among high school students necessitate a closer examination of which school-based strategies have been… more →
Compounded Disadvantage: Intersectional Inequities in Chronic Absenteeism Prevalence and Recovery During the COVID-19 Era
This study applies an intersectional lens to examine how chronic absenteeism evolved across race, sex, economic disadvantage, disability, and housing instability before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic using data from Georgia. Consistent with national evidence, chronic absenteeism nearly doubled and remained elevated through 2023, but recovery followed distinct racialized trajectories.… more →
Cost Efficiency of U.S. School Districts: Stochastic Frontier Evidence from the National Education Cost Model
I estimate the technical efficiency of U.S. school districts in producing middle-grades achievement with a stochastic frontier model built on the National Education Cost Model (NECM), which measures each district’s spending relative to the predicted cost of national-average outcomes. Because outcomes are measured in standard-deviation units, efficiency is expressed in input terms: the share of a… more →
More than Just Suspension: Informal Discipline in K-12 Schools
In this paper we document the prevalence and distribution of informal disciplinary consequences in K-12 public schools and examine how they contribute to disparities in school discipline. Using administrative data from North Carolina, we first describe the landscape of informal consequences across grade levels. Informal consequences are the most common disciplinary response in the early… more →
The Effects of Four-Day School Weeks in Texas
Four-day school weeks (FDSWs) have expanded rapidly in Texas in recent years. Districts cite teacher retention and recruitment as the primary motivation, though little is known about the impacts of FDSWs in this context. We study the effects of FDSW adoption on students and teachers in Texas using a staggered differences-in-differences design with a propensity score matched control group. We find… more →
Assessment Design and Course Grades: Evidence from Linked College Syllabi and Grade Records
Grade inflation is of increasing concern on college campuses, yet little is known about the course-level practices associated with higher grades. We examine one such practice: assessment design. Using syllabi from more than 400 undergraduate courses at four public universities, we identify criterion-relevant (CR) assessments—which require comparable demonstrations of knowledge or skill that can… more →
Fathers as Caregivers: Peer Exposure to Household Gender Roles and Girls’ Beliefs and Achievement
Gender roles are shaped within families, but whether family gender-role arrangements extend beyond households and influence other children remains unclear. This paper studies whether exposure to peers from father-dominant caregiving households affects students’ gender beliefs and educational outcomes. Using nationally representative data from Chinese middle schools and exploiting quasi-random… more →
Family Language Transmission Under Institutional Language Regimes Shapes Adolescent Mental Health Through Peers
In many societies, institutional languages shape participation, recognition, and belonging, while families transmit language backgrounds across generations. These inherited backgrounds may shape children’s communication and, once they enter shared classrooms, the experiences of their peers. This paper examines whether family language environments generate spillovers beyond the household through… more →
Nowcasting Teacher Turnover
Policymakers need timely, local information about teacher turnover to make informed decisions, yet turnover data are typically several years out of date and lack the context to assess whether a district's turnover is high or low relative to similar districts. We assemble district-level teacher turnover data from every state from 2003-04 to 2024-25, along with education, labor market, and economic… more →
Title I and IDEA as Complementary Federal Responses: Distinguishing Opportunity-Mediated and Opportunity-Independent Underachievement
Title I and IDEA are complementary federal responses to different sources of low achievement: each addresses needs that the other does not fully address. Title I targets opportunity-mediated underachievement, or low achievement linked to limited educational opportunity, while IDEA addresses persistent learning needs for which educational opportunity is not the primary explanation. This commentary… more →
Geographic and Community Correlates of College Savings: Evidence from the Universe of Pennsylvania 529 Accounts
College savings behaviors are associated with students’ postsecondary enrollment and degree attainment. While prior research has focused on economic and sociological influences, less is known about how geographic and community factors relate to savings. Using administrative data on nearly 200,000 Pennsylvania 529 accounts linked with community-level indicators, this study explores how place… more →
How Much Do Principals Matter When Politicians Choose Them? Evidence from Dated Successions and Close Elections in Brazil
Estimates of how much school principals matter differ by an order of magnitude, in part because conventional estimators require principal identifiers and absorb sampling noise into the estimated dispersion. We identify the variance of principal-by-school effects without identifiers, using successions dated by principals' reported tenure in Brazil's 2011 national assessment, which imply known… more →
What Districts Aim to Do: A Computational Mixed Methods Analysis of School District Strategic Plans
School districts are a distinct but long-critiqued feature of the United States educational system. Amid these critiques and increased public dissatisfaction with education, we revisit a fundamental question: What do school districts aim to do? Using a computational mixed methods analysis of 624 district strategic plans, we find that districts a) commit to a broad range of goals beyond student… more →
Legislating Literacy: Estimating the Impact of State-Level Science of Reading Reforms on Reading Test Scores
This study examines the extent to which state adoption of Science of Reading (SoR)-aligned policies was associated with changes in fourth-grade reading achievement. Using longitudinal state-level panel data from 2003-2024 and quasi-experimental difference-in-differences (DiD) methods, the study estimates relationships between SoR policy adoption and NAEP Grade 4 reading outcomes. Findings suggest… more →
Screen or Barrier? Science of Reading Certification Exams and Teacher Supply in Texas
Twenty states now require prospective teachers to pass a standalone Science of Reading (SOR) exam. These exams restrict teacher supply as a barrier, and whether they are worth that cost depends on whether they also screen on teaching quality. This paper explores this tension in Texas' SOR exam, required since 2021 for new elementary and middle-grades candidates, using administrative data linking… more →
Integrated vs. Separated Schooling for Refugee Children: Long-Term Effects on Education and Assimilation
Does direct integration into native schools or temporary placement in separate schools better promote the education and cultural assimilation of refugee children? In the Netherlands, primary-school-aged refugee children are placed in either integrated or separated schools depending on their randomly assigned municipality. By contrast, all secondary-school-aged arrivals are initially separated. We… more →
The Time Costs of Academic Credit Hours
Do students give up free time with added classes? We estimate the effect of additional credits on leisure using campus departure logs linked to academic records of U.S. Air Force Academy students and two natural experiments. Leveraging pre-assigned schedules, each credit reduces leisure by 7 hours per semester, while unexpected changes to graduation requirements crowded out 17 hours. Foregone… more →
Designing Effective Public-Private Partnerships in Education
Publicly funded school choice is examined as a form of education public-private partnership (PPP), with cross-national differences interpreted through institutional design rather than private provision alone. A novel theoretical framework derives two indicators – alignment and coherence – from a formal utility-theoretic model of PPP maturity, applied here for the first time to education. Across… more →
One Fell Through the Safety Net: Embeddedness and Take Up of Social Benefits
The U.S. social safety net comprises a patchwork quilt of welfare programs, but not all eligible beneficiaries receive aid. Incomplete take-up suggests that some children and families are not receiving access to the education, healthcare, housing, and income needed to break the cycle of poverty and may reflect unequal burdens in accessing benefits. We examine incomplete take-up using the case of… more →
Teacher-Mediated Multimodal Platform and Math Achievement: Evidence from Goblins' Yearlong District Implementation
Despite the rapid adoption of AI-powered learning tools in K–12 classrooms, there is limited evidence about their effectiveness in improving student learning. This paper examines the usage of Goblins—a teacher-mediated multimodal AI math platform that allows students to type, draw, and speak while receiving personalized feedback—and how that usage associates with middle school math achievement.… more →
Career ready or not? The relationship of WorkKeys scores, ACT scores, and high school GPAs with college and early-career outcomes
Growing efforts to ensure that students graduate high school both college- and career-ready raise a need for better understanding and measures of “career readiness.” We leverage data from one state (North Carolina) where nearly half of students take a college entrance exam (the ACT) in 11th grade and a career readiness exam (the WorkKeys) in 12th grade to examine how these different measures of… more →
Talent at the Top: Effects of Taxation on University Presidents’ Compensation and Priorities
College presidents are among the highest-paid individuals in higher education, and in 2017 the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act increased their cost to their institutions via a 21% excise tax on nonprofit executive compensation above $1 million. I examine how private colleges and universities and their presidents responded using an event study design. Presidential compensation fell by 13%, with the entire… more →
Improvements in Using Distance to Predict College Enrollment
Geographic proximity to college is a widely used instrument for estimating returns to postsecondary education. Most applications rely on geodesic ("crow-flies") distance, which is easy to calculate but a poor proxy for actual travel costs when terrain, water, or congestion intervene. We show that replacing geodesic distance with driving distance or driving time substantially strengthens… more →
The Impact of Exam Schools on Disadvantaged Students: Evidence from NYC’s Discovery Program
This paper studies the New York City Department of Education's Discovery Program, an affirmative action policy implemented to increase access to some of New York City’s most elite public high schools. The Discovery Program allocates reserve seats at New York City’s exam schools to disadvantaged students who successfully complete the course requirements of a summer program. Using a regression… more →
Beyond the Special Education Gap: Differences in Special Education Expenditures Between Charter Schools and Traditional Public Schools
Researchers and policymakers have long noted differences in disability enrollment and placement between charter schools and traditional public schools (TPSs), yet little is known about whether these differences correspond to special education expenditures. Using Texas administrative and financial data from 2019-20 to 2024-25, we compare special education expenditures, disability composition, and… more →
Defaults, Discretion, and Local Capacity: District Leaders’ Accounts of Automatic English Learner Reclassification
Automatic policies, which produce a preferred outcome unless implementers act otherwise, are rare in K-12 education and have been studied almost entirely using quantitative methods. In 2019, Michigan replaced its district-led procedure for reclassifying students out of English learner (EL) status with an automatic, state-led one. Drawing on interviews with 17 district EL leaders across 14… more →